Developing a public-interest training commons of books

Posted December 5, 2024
Photo by Zetong Li on Unsplash

Authors Alliance is pleased to announce a new project, supported by the Mellon Foundation, to develop an actionable plan for a public-interest book training commons for artificial intelligence. Northeastern University Library will be supporting this project and helping to coordinate its progress.

Access to books will play an essential role in how artificial intelligence develops. AI’s Large Language Models (LLMs) have a voracious appetite for text, and there are good reasons to think that these data sets should include books and lots of them. Over the last 500 years, human authors have written over 129 million books. These volumes, preserved for future generations in some of our most treasured research libraries, are perhaps the best and most sophisticated reflection of all human thinking. Their high editorial quality, breadth, and diversity of content, as well as the unique way they employ long-form narratives to communicate sophisticated and nuanced arguments and ideas make them ideal training data sources for AI.

These collections and the text embedded in them should be made available under ethical and fair rules as the raw material that will enable the computationally intense analysis needed to inform new AI models, algorithms, and applications imagined by a wide range of organizations and individuals for the benefit of humanity. 

Currently, AI development is dominated by a handful of companies that, in their rush to beat other competitors, have paid insufficient attention to the diversity of their inputs, questions of truth and bias in their outputs, and questions about social good and access. Authors Alliance, Northeastern University Library, and our partners seek to correct this tilt through the swift development of a counterbalancing project that will focus on AI development that builds upon the wealth of knowledge in nonprofit libraries and that will be structured to consider the views of all stakeholders, including authors, publishers, researchers, technologists, and stewards of collections. 

The main goal of this project is to develop a plan for either establishing a new organization or identifying the relevant criteria for an existing organization (or partnership of organizations) to take on the work of creating and stewarding a large-scale public interest training commons of books.

We seek to answer several key questions, such as: 

  • What are the right goals and mission for such an effort, taking into account both the long and short-term;
  • What are the technical and logistical challenges that might differ from existing library-led efforts to provide access to collections as data;
  • How to develop a sufficiently large and diverse corpus to offer a reasonable alternative to existing sources;
  • What a public-interest governance structure should look like that takes into account the particular challenges of AI development;
  • How do we, as a collective of stakeholders from authors and publishers to students, scholars, and libraries, sustainably fund such a commons, including a model for long-term sustainability for maintenance, transformation, and growth of the corpus over time;
  • Which combination of legal pathways is acceptable to ensure books are lawfully acquired in a way that minimizes legal challenges;
  • How to respect the interests of authors and rightsholders by accounting for concerns about consent, credit, and compensation; and
  • How to distinguish between the different needs and responsibilities of nonprofit researchers, small market entrants, and large commercial actors.

The project will include two meetings during 2025 to discuss these questions and possible ways forward, additional research and conversations with stakeholders, and the development and release of an ambitious yet achievable roadmap.